Comparative study of cleft lip repair between
the Millard and Fisher methods.
Dr. Nikolaos Kechagias1, Dr. Elias Tourtounis2
1st Hellenic Cleft Center & Division Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery, St. Louke's Hospital Panorama, Thessaloniki (Director:
Prof. N. Kechagias)
DOI: 10.54936/haoms272129137
SUMMARY: In the study of cleft lip reconstruction techniques, that took place in the 1st Hellenic Cleft Centre the modified rotary flap (Millard technique) is widely used. However, the new approach to anatomical design is gaining popularity (Fisher techniue). The goal of this
study is to compare the results of the two surgical techniques performed by the same surgeon. Materials & Method: qualitative measurements were made preoperative and postoperative photographs of cleft lip reconstructions in 38 cases of unilateral cleft lip.
Parameters such as lip height, lip width, red vermilion height and nasal base (wing) width, etc. were measured.
A percentage aesthetic ratio of the normal side to the cleft side for each outcome was used as a quantitative
measure. The ualitative analysis of cleft repair was assessed using the Steffensen criteria. Nineteen cases
were restored using the Millard techniue and nineteen with the Fisher technique. The restorations were evaluated
in percentage terms () where the aesthetic ratio of the restoration to the perfect ratio was judged. In cases with complete cleft lip asymmetry was observed in the height of the lip, the height of the red border, and the base of the nose for both techniues, as well as a percentage difference between the techniues. Results of the study show that in both incomplete cleft lip and complete cleft lip, the Millard technique seems to present more asymmetry parameters than the Fisher technique. For the most part, it is observed that the Fisher technique is less dependent on the severity of the cleft and appears more reliable in the repair of unilateral cleft lip.
REFERENCES
1. Goodacre T, Swan MC. Cleft lip and palate: Current management. Paediatr Child Health 200818:283–292.
2. Demke JC, Tatum SA. Analysis and evolution of rotation principles in unilateral cleft lip repair. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg.
201164:313–318.
3. Millard DR Jr. Rotation-advancement principle in cleft lip closure. Cleft Palate J. 196412:246–252.
4. Kuna SK, Srinath N, Naveen S, Hasan K. Comparison of outcome of modifed Millards incision and Delaires functional
method in primary repair of unilateral cleft lip: A prospective study. J Maxillofac Oral Surg. 201615:221–228.
5. Reddy GS, ebb RM, Reddy RR, Reddy LV, Thomas P, Markus AF. Choice of incision for primary repair of unilateral
complete cleft lip: A comparative study of outcomes in 796 patients. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2008121:932–940.
6. Fisher DM. Unilateral cleft lip repair: An anatomical subunit approximation techniue. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2005116:61–71.
7. Cutting C, Dayan JH. Lip height and lip width after extended Mohler unilateral cleft lip repair. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2003111:17–23 discussion 24–26.
8. Rossell-Perry P. A 20-year experience in unilateral cleft lip repair: From Millard to the triple unilimb Z-plasty technique. Indian J Plast Surg. 201649:340–349.
9. Mbuyi-Musanzayi S, Tshilombo Katombe F, Lukusa Tshilobo P, Kalenga Mwenze Kayamba P, Devriendt K, Reychler H. Anthropometric
and aesthetic outcomes for the nasolabial region in 101 consecutive African children with unilateral cleft lip one year after repair using the anatomical subunit approximation technique. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 201746:1338–1345
1st Hellenic Cleft Center & Division Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery, St. Louke's Hospital Panorama, Thessaloniki (Director:
Prof. N. Kechagias)
DOI: 10.54936/haoms272129137
SUMMARY: In the study of cleft lip reconstruction techniques, that took place in the 1st Hellenic Cleft Centre the modified rotary flap (Millard technique) is widely used. However, the new approach to anatomical design is gaining popularity (Fisher techniue). The goal of this
study is to compare the results of the two surgical techniques performed by the same surgeon. Materials & Method: qualitative measurements were made preoperative and postoperative photographs of cleft lip reconstructions in 38 cases of unilateral cleft lip.
Parameters such as lip height, lip width, red vermilion height and nasal base (wing) width, etc. were measured.
A percentage aesthetic ratio of the normal side to the cleft side for each outcome was used as a quantitative
measure. The ualitative analysis of cleft repair was assessed using the Steffensen criteria. Nineteen cases
were restored using the Millard techniue and nineteen with the Fisher technique. The restorations were evaluated
in percentage terms () where the aesthetic ratio of the restoration to the perfect ratio was judged. In cases with complete cleft lip asymmetry was observed in the height of the lip, the height of the red border, and the base of the nose for both techniues, as well as a percentage difference between the techniues. Results of the study show that in both incomplete cleft lip and complete cleft lip, the Millard technique seems to present more asymmetry parameters than the Fisher technique. For the most part, it is observed that the Fisher technique is less dependent on the severity of the cleft and appears more reliable in the repair of unilateral cleft lip.
REFERENCES
1. Goodacre T, Swan MC. Cleft lip and palate: Current management. Paediatr Child Health 200818:283–292.
2. Demke JC, Tatum SA. Analysis and evolution of rotation principles in unilateral cleft lip repair. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg.
201164:313–318.
3. Millard DR Jr. Rotation-advancement principle in cleft lip closure. Cleft Palate J. 196412:246–252.
4. Kuna SK, Srinath N, Naveen S, Hasan K. Comparison of outcome of modifed Millards incision and Delaires functional
method in primary repair of unilateral cleft lip: A prospective study. J Maxillofac Oral Surg. 201615:221–228.
5. Reddy GS, ebb RM, Reddy RR, Reddy LV, Thomas P, Markus AF. Choice of incision for primary repair of unilateral
complete cleft lip: A comparative study of outcomes in 796 patients. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2008121:932–940.
6. Fisher DM. Unilateral cleft lip repair: An anatomical subunit approximation techniue. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2005116:61–71.
7. Cutting C, Dayan JH. Lip height and lip width after extended Mohler unilateral cleft lip repair. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2003111:17–23 discussion 24–26.
8. Rossell-Perry P. A 20-year experience in unilateral cleft lip repair: From Millard to the triple unilimb Z-plasty technique. Indian J Plast Surg. 201649:340–349.
9. Mbuyi-Musanzayi S, Tshilombo Katombe F, Lukusa Tshilobo P, Kalenga Mwenze Kayamba P, Devriendt K, Reychler H. Anthropometric
and aesthetic outcomes for the nasolabial region in 101 consecutive African children with unilateral cleft lip one year after repair using the anatomical subunit approximation technique. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 201746:1338–1345
How to cite this article:
|
View the full-text PDF:
|
| ||||||